My eyes a very small and my eyelashes are short and sparse. Over the years, I’ve tried countless mascaras, from drugstore brands to high-end—and after a long search, I’ve finally found three that work especially well for small, hooded eyes. Two are high-end, but in my opinion, they’re worth every penny.
1. Urban Decay Perversion Mascara
Retail: $22.00 | Available at Sephora or the Urban Decay website
This creamy formula adds both volume and length without clumping. It separates each lash, making eyes appear larger. While the brand claims it contains proteins and amino acids to stimulate lash growth, I haven’t noticed a difference. I use this mascara for what I call my “day makeup”, work, errands, and everyday activities.
2. IT Cosmetics Superhero Mascara
Retail: $24.00 | Available at Ulta or QVC
For a bold, nighttime look, this mascara is a must-have. One coat gives extreme volume and length, and while additional coats can clump slightly, I actually like this because it makes my small eyes appear bigger. Perfect for parties or special occasions.
3. Maybelline Lash Discovery Mascara
Retail: $7.99 | Available at most drugstores
This mascara lengthens and defines lashes without clumping. For my small eyes, it separates each lash for a clean, natural look. I reach for this one on no-makeup makeup days, at the gym, or swimming (it’s waterproof), or anytime I just want to look more awake.